It has been rightly said that the relationship between lenin and stalin is certainly one of the most complex problems that has to be faced in. Stalin, communism, leninism, bolshevism, lenin, china, mao. Trotsky, and stalin were the first to sign the statement contain ing the threat. Joseph stalin, the foundations of leninism, 1924, marxism and the national question, 19 erik van ree, stalin as marxist. Leninism is marxism of the era of imperialism and the proletarian revolution. Lenin and trotsky were the two who made the russian socialist revolution possible while the majority of bolsheviks, stalin included, said it was not possible. I t has been rightly said that the relationship between lenin and stalin is certainly one of the most complex problems that has to be faced in studying soviet history and analysing stalinism. The question of whether or not stalinism was a logical continuation of leninism is a difficult one.
Stalin considered himself a marxistleninist, that is, a successor to the theories of marx which were extrapolated upon by lenin. Stalinism and how stalin used his power to change marxismleninism. Marxismleninism is a political philosophy that seeks to establish a socialist state to develop. Stalin waged a lifelong struggle to defend marxismleninism and the dictatorship of the proletariat.
However, despite his emphasis on the role of revolutionary theory. The roles of lenin and stalin in the russian revolution. Expounding the foundations of leninism does not yet mean. Problems of leninism, volume 19 joseph stalin snippet view 1934. In the introduction, stalin uses a questionandanswer format. From commissar to general secretary service, chapters 1722 week four. Although some of stalins policies were different from those of lenin, what difference stalinism did show from leninism were either policies which lenin had called for but never put into action, or logical continuations of lenins original principles, but modified to suit the demands of the time. Stalin problems of leninism table of contents the following is an abbreviated version of the table of contents, listing only the titles of the documents contained in problems of leninism. Aug 26, 2010 leninism is a term that comes from a disagreement between early russian social democrates and socialists. In the most basic comparison we can clearly see a difference in ow each of them view the use of violence and force. Stalins religious policy was driven by a kind of russification because religion a sign of regional identity, so he is harsher to nonchristians than lenin.
However, it is of absolute importance that we understand leninism is not. The policies of lenin and stalin essay 2283 words 10 pages identified within this study is the argument that whilst many of lenins theories and practices were continued under stalin, many were in fact developed and extended to new levels, possibly reflecting different motives. From leninism to stalinism a logical progression nonaggression pact with adolf hitler on august 23, 1939. If the relationship of leninism to marxism is a hotly contested matter, so too is the relationship of leninism to stalinism. The dictatorship of the proletariat arises not on the basis of the bourgeois order, but in the process of the breaking up of this order, after the overthrow of the bourgeoisie, in the process of the expropriation of the landlords and capitalists, in the process of the socialisation of the principal instruments and means of. Lenin and trotsky didnt care for their personal comfort or wealth and dedicated all th.
Archpriest of leninism, stalin also promoted his own cult in the following year by having the city of tsaritsyn renamed stalingrad now volgograd. Should we cross paths with either trotsky or stalins claim over leninism, there is more truth in stalin stalinism was the continuation of leninism in accordance with material conditions in existence within the soviet union. Stalinism and how stalin used his power to change marxism. Until shortly before his death, lenin countered stalins disproportionate political influence. Lenin and stalin happen to be the most prominent and influential leaders of modern soviet union.
Hence leninism is not different from marxism but it is the further development of marxism. The foundations of leninism marxists internet archive. But in spite of these, stalinism still found its basis in leninism. A woman is flanked by portraits of soviet leader joseph stalin and russian revolutionary vladimir lenin as the russian communist party rallies to mark the centenary of the 1917 bolshevik revolution. Bolshevik experience, the revolution and its crisis. The article appears as the third article in this book which, as noted above, bears the name problems of. Valentino gerratana, stalin, lenin and leninism, nlr i103, may. After lenins death, in january 1924, stalin promoted an extravagant, quasibyzantine cult of the deceased leader. The term came into prominence during the mid1930s when lazar kaganovich, a soviet politician and associate of stalin, reportedly declared. However, in 1926, joseph stalin had proposed the theory of building socialism in one state as an alternative to the theory of permanent revolution. Stalinism did take significantly more drastic measures than leninism did.
To put it simply, history consists of a ruling class which commands the means of production and. The policies of lenin and stalin essay 2283 words bartleby. The national question and leninism by stalin, 1929 youtube. Joseph stalin 18781953 was the dictator of the union of soviet socialist republics ussr from 1929 to 1953. The sixth volume opens with comrade stalin s interview with a rosta correspondent entitled the dis. Among stalins writings translated into english are leninism tr.
Stalin himself was an old bolshevik and not one of the least that lenin led and inspired. While stalin ruled for almost three decades and was the successor of lenin, it was lenin who remains the father figure and a creator of modern day communist ussr which ended in 1990 though. Stalin dismissed this as excessively praiseful and contributing to a cult of personality. Lenins achievements and plunged the soviet union into misery and oppression from which it never recovered. One of the two major anthologies of stalin s principal theoretical works, including the foundations of leninism, concerning questions of leninism, the right deviation in the c. The dictatorship of the proletariat arises not on the basis of the bourgeois order, but in the process of the breaking up of this order, after the overthrow of the bourgeoisie, in the process of the expropriation of the landlords and capitalists, in the process of the socialisation of the principal instruments and. A woman is flanked by portraits of soviet leader joseph stalin and russian revolutionary vladimir lenin as the russian communist party rallies. Stalinism definition of stalinism by merriamwebster. May 11, 2007 in fact, as long as lenin was active, stalin was no trouble to him, however troublesome he may have been to the number two bolshevik. Theorists of totalitarianism assert that the theoretical, psychological and institutional bases of the stalinist aspiration for total control over society and individuals was firmly established by lenin. Learn about his younger years, his rise to power and his brutal reign that caused. Dictatorship of the proletariat necessary to complete the victory over the bourgeoisie 3.
Lets replace long live leninism with long live stalinism. The foundations of leninism chapter 8 by stalin, 1924. Indeed, a whole number of volumes would be required. Marxists internet archive archive, may 2008 transcription. Joseph stalin was born in gori, georgia, on 21 december 1879. Marxism was defined by a man named karl marx and his associate fredrich engels. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Jan 23, 2015 the national question and leninism reply to comrades meshkov, kovalchuk, and others march 18, 1929 source. Twenty odd years ago joseph stalin rtceivtd a number of letters raising problems in connection with the national question and asking him far eluadation. Still, in order for trotsky to explain the soviet thermidor, there must be a difference between leninism and stalinism, provided, of course, there was such a thermidor.
The sixth volume opens with comrade stalins interview with a rosta correspondent entitled the dis. From leninism to stalinism a logical progression, history. Proletariat unite and overthrow the bourgeoisie marx believes this is inevitable 2. The works of comrade stalin included in the present volume played a cardinal part in the ideological defeat of trotskyism and other antileninist groups, in the defence, substantiation and development of leninism.
Stalin dismissed this as excessively praiseful and contributing to. The five classics of marxism leninism in the espresso stalinist banner are. Archived pdf from the original on 10 november 2016. Leninism is a political theory developed by russian revolutionary vladimir lenin that proposes the establishment of the dictatorship of the proletariat, led by a revolutionary vanguard party, as the political prelude to the establishment of socialism. The marxistleninistmaoist class interest theory of ethics by scott harrison draft as of 6908 chapters 1 and 2 only.
Stalin, 18791953, was able to meet and saw off this challenge, to the extent that trotskyism became a marginal, exterior tendency in relation to the communist movement. Later the name of this article was changed to the more accurate name concerning questions of leninism. One feature of marxism, often ignored, is emphasized in this classic sentence in a striking manner. The claim that leninism inexorably led to stalinism should not be accepted uncritically either. Karl marx, friedrich engels, vladimir lenin, joseph stalin, enver hoxha. The difference between marxism, leninism, stalinism. The foundations of leninism can be understood as one way he developed this cult and his role in it. The progression from leninism to stalinism essay 1405 words. What were the key differences between lenin and stalin. In addition to a focus on socialism only within his own country, stalin also focused on a concentration of governmental control of industry and agriculture. Ever since lenin died in 1924, trotskyism has challenged marxismleninism for the ideological leadership of the international communist movement. Contemporary marxismleninismmaoism by the communist party of turkeymarxistleninist tkpml summer 1998 our doctrine, said engels about his and his famous friends doctrine, is not a dogma, but a guide to action. Furthermore, we should continue discussion on the role of stalin and his allies in the formation of the u.
With that, stalins application of marxismleninism to the situation of the soviet union. Marxism uses the hegelian framework of historical development and establishes materialism and class conflict as the driving force of this development. The marxistleninistmaoist class interest theory of ethics. It is the application of marxism the purpose of which is the emancipation of the proletariat. Revolution spreads around the world again, marx felt this was inevitable. A great marxistleninist leader of the international working class.
Problems of leninism, which appeared in 11 editions during his lifetime, sets forth an ideology of power and activism that rides roughshod over the more nuanced approach of lenin. The other, a no less compulsive apology for marxism, ingenuously denies any connection at all between marxism leninism and stalinism, even though all stalinists were proud to call themselves both. Leninism is a political theory developed by russian revolutionary vladimir lenin that proposes. Lenin followed marxism, stalin did not essay 1781 words. What is the difference between marxism, leninism, stalinism. Lenin believed that the trade union movement could not manifest any revolutionary potential without guidence from a vanguard group of professional revolutionaries who would constitute the real power behind the revolutionary movement. He was expelled from school for neglecting his studies and found work at the citys meteorological observatory over the next decade. December 21 marks the 107th anniversary of the birth of one of the greatest leaders of the international working class, joseph stalin. The contents of those texts containing sections and subsections can be accessed by way of the link more that follows a title. Even trotsky, a friend of lenin and a staunch opponent of stalin, grudgingly admits that stalinism did issue from bolshevism trotsky. Valentino gerratana, stalin, lenin and leninism, nlr i103.
The crisis did nevertheless lead to the formation of a new government which. A documentary history of communism in russia from lenin to gorbachev edited, with introduction, notes, and original translations by robert v. Catherine merridale looks at the differences between the two leaders, in particular their attitudes towards violence. Daniels university of vermont press burlington, vermont published by university press of new england hanover and london. Stalin and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. One of the two major anthologies of stalins principal theoretical works, including the foundations of leninism, concerning questions of leninism, the right deviation in the c. Naturally, therefore, my lectures cannot be an exhaustive exposition of leninism. Publication date 1947 topics cdac collection digitallibraryindia. Lenin enriched marxism, ensured its success now the working class and its ideologues call it marxism leninism, stalin upheld marxism leninism in principle as well as in practice, further enriched it, aided the world proletarian class to march ahead, defeating the enemy class, the imperialist capitalism. Lenin specifically forbids the party to compel the peasants to go into collectives stalin does the direct opposite of this. What are the differences between trotskyism, leninism and. Stalins problems of leninism corresponds to the eleventh.
Eur1 what did lenin and stalin contribute to communism in. He seemed to derive personal satisfaction from pushing the soviet union to the brink. Stalin does not agree with the view that leninism is the application of marxism to the conditions peculiar to the situation in russia. The article appears as the third article in this book which, as noted above, bears the name problems of leninism. Stalin had published this theory in his pamphlet called on the problems of leninism. Secretary of state carried with him joseph stalin s problems of leninism and impressed upon his aides the need to study it as a blueprint for conquest similar to adolf hitlers mein kampf. The foundations of leninism by stalin, 1924 source. Secretary of state carried with him joseph stalins problems of leninism and impressed upon his aides the need to study it as a blueprint for conquest similar to adolf hitlers mein kampf. To be more exact, leninism is the theory and tactics of the proletarian revolution in general, the theory and tactics of the dictatorship of. Jun 05, 2014 for these reasons, i argue that lenin and stalin should be decoupled in our minds and discourse. While stalin in his selfappointed role of philosopherstatesman sought to extend and amplify leninism the alleged marxism of the 20th century he never attempted to infringe his masters on the subject. The difference between marxism, leninism, stalinism, and maoism i. As the left opposition to stalin within the soviet party and government, leon trotsky and trotskyists argued that marxistleninist ideology contradicted marxism and leninism in theory, therefore stalins ideology was not useful for the implementation of socialism in russia. Basically, marxism is defined as a conflict theory, as marx said that society is separated by a conflict between the rich and the poor.
The progression from leninism to stalinism essay 1405. Lenin was not above violence although he did aspire for the soviet union to be a peaceful and democratic institution. His father was a shoemaker and his mother a domestic servant. Stalin believed leninism to be the natural evolution of marxist theory. Stalins writings form no cohesive body of political theory, although he claimed to represent the pure interpretation of leninism and marxism. The pamphlet the foundations of leninism contains a definition of leninism which seems to have received general recognition. Although lenin and stalin had tensions that year, when lenin died, stalin immediately took advantage by appointing himself the leader of the lenin cult. After 1929, stalin, more concerned with strengthening his own personal power than with furthering communist revolution, destroyed. What are the differences between communism, marxism, maoism. Stalinism definition is the political, economic, and social principles and policies associated with stalin. I realize that they were all communists, but ive always been curious as to their particular differences, when did lenin veer away from marxism, and what did mao and stalin do differently or the same as stalin.
1276 1077 1229 1205 1225 1064 834 265 850 747 640 913 638 1230 582 743 1349 213 35 603 1260 469 1365 532 678 384 606 398 823 780 350 1090 552 1287 1104 1106